January 2024 ECB Preview: Pushback Falling On Deaf Ears

Michael Brown
Market Analyst
The first ECB decision of the year comes at an interesting time for the Governing Council, with disinflation across the eurozone continuing, while downside economic risks continue to mount, and markets price an increasingly aggressive path of policy easing over the course of 2024. It is this easing, and the vast divergence between the dovish outlook foreseen by money markets, and the rate trajectory projected by policymakers, that is likely to be the focus of the upcoming decision.

It should, largely, go without saying that the deposit rate will be maintained at a record-high 4%, with OIS implying such a hold as a near-certainty. In fact, at this late stage of the economic cycle, it would take a significant inflationary shock to result in a further rate hike, and even in such an unlikely scenario, with economic momentum waning rapidly, such a move is far from guaranteed.


As noted, however, it is the remainder of 2024 where the policy outlook becomes significantly more interesting, and where a chasm opens between the views of Governing Council members, and the path markets currently price.

In light of inflationary pressures continuing to fade, EUR OIS has begun to price a rapid pace of easing throughout the year ahead, implying a roughly 4-in-5 chance that the first 25bp cut will be delivered by the April policy meeting, along with an expectation that as much as 140bp of total easing will be delivered of the year in its entirety.

Unsurprisingly, such a path, and the loosening in financial conditions that it has provoked, is of concern to policymakers. In fact, of the 17 who have spoken since the turn of the year, all but three have attempted to pushback on this dovish implied path, noting in one way or another that markets are “too optimistic” on the prospect of near-term cuts. Despite this deafening amount of rhetoric, it seems unlikely that the policy statement will be significantly altered, likely repeating the prior stance that rates will remain at “sufficiently restrictive levels for as long as necessary”.


Interestingly, though, recent remarks have largely fallen on deaf ears in terms of market reaction, with OIS pricing having hardly budged over the last fortnight, and the EUR also trading relatively flat over the same period. This, therefore, raises the question of whether the market will actually listen to whatever the ECB have to say at the January meeting, with recent form indicating that messaging will likely fall on deaf ears once more.

Perhaps the biggest reason for this divergence is the market’s focus on what policymakers ‘should’ do, rather than what they ‘will’ do. Recent inflation figures are perhaps the biggest cause of this, with the bloc continuing to experience relatively rapid disinflation, particularly on a core basis, with prices ex-food and energy having risen by 3.4% YoY in December, the slowest pace since April 2022. While headline inflation has ticked marginally higher, to 2.9% YoY, this was driven largely by energy-induced base effects, and is almost certain to be ignored in policy-setting discussions.


Nevertheless, while inflation continues to fade, the Governing Council will be loath to take a premature victory lap, with the experience of dismissing price pressures as ‘transitory’ in the period following the pandemic still fresh in most minds. Consequently, at the margin, the ECB’s reaction function is likely substantially more hawkish than markets currently estimate, likely leading to policymakers seeking as much evidence as possible of inflation having returned to the 2% target, before beginning to cut benchmark rates, likely putting the timing of any cuts into the second quarter at the earliest. This is in contrast to the market’s perceived view, that rates should be reduced in advance of inflation’s return to target, in an attempt to support growth, and stick a ‘soft landing’.

On the subject of growth, the eurozone economic outlook remains rather dour. The most recent round of PMI surveys pointed to a continued bloc-wide contraction across both the manufacturing and services sectors as 2023 drew to a close with both indices having now stagnated for around six months, implying a steady pace of declining output growth over said period. While January’s PMI round will be released a day prior to the ECB’s decision, the data is unlikely to differ significantly from recent trends.


Furthermore, risks to the economic outlook remain clearly tilted to the downside, already placing under threat the ECB’s forecast for an anaemic 0.8% pace of GDP growth this year. Said risks are numerous, and by this point well-documented, including Germany’s continued economic woes, the ongoing lack of recovery in China posing an increasingly stiff headwind, in addition to the recent surge in geopolitical tensions in the Middle East, with the eurozone particularly exposed to rising shipping costs as the Red Sea continues to be largely avoided.

A handful of other items are also worth covering off. Firstly, the ECB are highly unlikely to alter the balance sheet reduction plans unveiled last month, in that PEPP reinvestments will slowly be tapered in the second half of the year, before coming to a halt entirely at the end of 2024. Secondly, President Lagarde’s press conference will be closely watched for any additional policy guidance, with remarks likely to echo those made recently in Davos, whereby Lagarde noted that victory cannot be declared until inflation is ‘sustainably’ at 2%, and that it is ‘likely’ a cut could be delivered by the summer, though this latter remark was taken slightly out of context by headline writers.

Turning to financial markets where, as noted above, the scale of any significant reaction to the ECB’s first meeting of the year is somewhat uncertain. Not only have markets shown little desire to react to recent policy messaging, while 1-week implieds, covering the period over the decision, sit just over 6%, implying – with 1 standard deviation of confidence – an approximate move of +/- 80 pips in EUR/USD over the tenor.


In terms of spot, the common currency has been rather rangebound of late, trapped between the 200-day moving average to the downside, and the 50-day moving average above. While a closing break of either level may entice some to chase the move, long EUR positions on the basis of a hawkish ECB surprise still seem rather tough to justify, not least owing to the continued dismal growth backdrop, with a closing break below the recent 1.0850 low likely to see price test the 1.07 figure in relatively short order, notwithstanding some potential dip demand around the 100-day MA.


Pepperstone 并不表示此处提供的材料是准确、最新或完整的,因此不应依赖于此。该信息,无论是否来自第三方,都不应被视为推荐;或买卖要约;或征求购买或出售任何证券、金融产品或工具的要约;或参与任何特定的交易策略。它没有考虑读者的财务状况或投资目标。我们建议此内容的任何读者寻求自己的建议。未经 Pepperstone 批准,不得复制或重新分发此信息。